Episode Transcript

Do You Need a Colon Cleanse?
Episode 61: September 16, 2009

This week, I’m going to be talking about colon cleansing and detox regimens—something many of you have written to me about. Do you need to detox? And if so, what’s the best way to go about it?

Before we get started, a couple of quick announcements: There’s a new Quick and Dirty Tips podcast and this one couldn’t be any timelier.  The Dealista delivers insider tips to help you shop wisely, spend less, and get more for your money. The show goes way beyond generic tips about clipping coupons and shopping at warehouse stores. If you want to get more for your money, check out the Dealista on iTunes or on QuickandDirtytips.com.

Also, today’s show is brought to you by Audible, the internet’s best source of spoken word entertainment. Visit audiblepodcast.com/diva for a free download of your choice.

Should You Believe the Claims About Detox Regimens?

If you spend any time at all online, you’ve probably seen ads for various detox and cleansing programs. If you’ve clicked on any of these ads, you may have read some really scary stuff about all the toxic sludge that’s lurking in your body and some really amazing stories about how fantastic you’ll feel when you cleanse your body of all these poisons.

But many of you are appropriately skeptical. Tiffany is wondering whether colon cleansing is healthy and Kristen wants to know how often one should do it. Melissa wonders if detoxing is really necessary. Frank is suspicious of the claims he’s seen for products in late night infomercials and James wants to know how to separate the facts from the marketing hype.

Let’s take a closer look at colon cleansing first. Next week, I’ll talk about more general detox programs.

Do You Need a Colon Cleanse?

Advocates of colon cleansing claim that, left to its own devices, the large intestine tends to fill up with sludge--sort of like a clogged drain pipe. That sludge supposedly contains toxins which poison the body. They claim that most people are carrying around several pounds of this toxic build-up, which can be eliminated with colon cleansing, bringing about a dramatic improvement in your health and well-being.

Most of the GI docs I’ve asked about this--people who spend their time looking around inside people’s colons--say that this is nonsense. The amount of material in the large intestine varies greatly from person to person and day to day. However, except in cases involving impaction or extreme constipation, nothing in your colon, including the cells lining it, has been in there for more than a few days.

Secondly, colon cleansing will not help you lose weight. Most of the calories and nutrients in the foods you eat have been digested and absorbed by the time food reaches your large intestine. The pound a day that some programs promise you’ll lose is mostly water. So, though a colon cleansing product may be very effective at flushing dollars from your wallet, it is not going to flush fat from your body. Sorry.

Thirdly, cleansing does not necessarily enhance the health of the colon. Most colon cleanse programs are basically laxatives, administered from one end or the other. Taking laxatives, especially if you’re not constipated, isn’t a great idea. They can disrupt fluid and electrolyte balance and piss off the beneficial bacteria in your intestines. Regular use of laxatives can also, ironically, make you constipated.

The Scientific Evidence on Colon Cleansing

Now, let’s take a look at the scientific evidence that colon cleansing enhances mental clarity, immune function, complexion, arthritis, allergies, and energy levels. Oh, right. There isn’t any. 

So why do people report such miraculous results after cleansing their colons? It may also be partly psychological. If you’ve ever had abdominal surgery or a colonoscopy, you’ve cleansed your colon. Did it make you feel like a new person? Probably not, but then again, you probably weren’t expecting it to.

How to Improve Colon Health

If you really want to improve the health of your colon, here’s what I would recommend:

Instead of periodically taking extreme measures to “cleanse” your colon, adopt habits that promote colon health on an ongoing basis.

1. Eat more fiber and drink more water. As I explained in episode #46 on constipation, this combination helps to bulk up your stool and decrease the amount of time that waste spends in your gut.

2. Eat yogurt or other foods containing beneficial bacteria on a regular basis. In episode #4, on fermented foods, I talked about how these friendly flora help improve digestion, bolster immune function, and maintain the health of your colon.

3. Finally, if you like the idea of a cleaner colon, eat less junk. I mean, how do you think that stuff gets in there, anyway?

That’s my take on colon cleansing. Next week, I’ll talk more about programs and products that are designed to detox your liver, kidneys, and other organs.

To pass the time until then, why not visit audible and download a book you’ve been dying to read but just haven’t had the time for? You can get Richard Russo’s latest title, That Old Cape Magic, or Chris McDougall’s best-selling Born to Run. You can even listen to audio samples before you buy. And as a Nutrition Diva listener, your first download is free. Just visit audiblepodcast.com/diva for all the details.

Administrative

Visit nutritiondiva.quickanddirtytips.com for a transcript of this episode, along with links to past shows and some other resources on colon cleansing. Post your comments and questions on my Facebook page or Twitter! And for my listeners in Fredericksburg, VA, listen for me this Friday morning on the Chris and Dee show on B101.5

Have a great day and eat something good for me!

RESOURCES:

Gastrointestinal Quackery Steve Barrett, MD for Quackwatch

How Clean Should Your Colon Be? American Council on Science and Health


Comments (6) for Do You Need a Colon Cleanse? |  Subscribe to Comment

Nutrition Diva Says:
10/9/2009 9:48:41 AM
@Shannon: Ironic, isn't it? I don't choose which ads display here...they're served up by Google in response to keywords. Obviously, the searchbots can only discern that I'm talking about colon cleansing, not what I'm saying. ;-)
Shannon Says:
10/7/2009 2:30:19 PM
Not sure if you realize that there is an ad for a colon cleanse product on this page,.. kind of a mixed message
annmarie Says:
9/30/2009 11:06:04 PM
I just started a colon cleanse along with acai berry a little over a week ago and I really do feel better, I have literally my belly and lost weight. I went from almost a size 10 to snuggly fitting in a size 6 this week, honestly all I have done is go to the bathroom 3-4 times a day, but I had an extremely bloated stomach which has gone done significantly!!! I normally am leary of these types of claims but I have seen the benefits of acai berry and a cleanse. I was also always bloated and gassy and that has improved if not gone..I am not selling anything believe me. I was able to wear my medium strech cotton blouse to work today, I used to just try it on and end up throwing it back in the closet when i was unable to button it, I hear the skeptics but I see the results.
Lizzie Says:
9/21/2009 11:24:02 AM
I have seen these TV infomercials and have really considered looking into it to improve my health and energy, among all the other good things they claim will come. I am glad that you addressed this, and thank you for saving my money, and my digestive system :0)
sue Says:
9/16/2009 1:44:17 PM
Good info! Funny that the advertisement at the end of the article was for a colon cleanser!
jesssica Says:
9/16/2009 11:49:31 AM
Thanks for doing a show on this. I was actually just thinking about emailing this same question to you ... and then a link to it appeared in my inbox! Very helpful info...

Add Comment

 *
 *
 *
  Image to deter spam submissions
  To deter spam submissions, please type the letters from the image into the box below:
 *
 
  Fields marked with "*" are required